My Top Picks for Peppermint-Flavored Chewing Gums (2024)

Finding the right peppermint chewing gum can be a mix of navigating flavor, health considerations, and personal diet preferences. From aspartame-free gums to those packed with natural sweeteners, my taste buds have been through a refreshing journey. I’ll share my honest thoughts on each, helping you decide which gum might refresh your day the best.

1. PUR Aspartame-free Chewing Gum

The PUR Company’s aspartame-free gum is quite a catch for anyone steering clear of synthetic sweeteners. Sweetened with xylitol, it promises a decent flavor kick initially, though the intensity does wane sooner than I’d like. At around $5 for a 55-piece pack, it’s a fair price for those prioritizing a vegan and keto-friendly option. Still, the details about the gum base remain elusive, leaving a bit to be desired on transparency.

2. Simply Gum Classic Natural Chewing Gum

Simply Gum offers a natural chew with a base of chicle and cane sugar as a sweetener, setting it apart from others with its minimally processed ingredients. The flavor is delightfully minty with a lasting impression. However, for about $15 for six packs, it’s a pricier indulgence, and the texture might feel slightly grainy for some.

3. Spry Sugar-free Chewing Gum with Xylitol

Spry’s gum, boosted by xylitol and a hint of stevia, brings a refreshing taste without the guilt, perfect for those watching their sugar intake. Priced at approximately $9 for 100 pieces, it offers good value. Nevertheless, the flavor does not stick around as long as I would hope, which can be a bit disappointing.

4. Epic Sugar-free Chewing Gum with Xylitol

Packed with xylitol, Epic Dental’s gum emphasizes dental health and a strong punch of peppermint. It’s quite effective at delivering an initial zing, and a bottle of 50 pieces for about $6 feels reasonable. Yet again, the flavor fades more swiftly than ideal and the ingredients list could use more clarity regarding the gum base.

5. Trident Sugar-free Chewing Gum

Trident is a familiar face in the gum aisle, blending sorbitol, xylitol, and aspartame among other sweeteners. It’s a versatile choice for those adhering to a diabetic or keto lifestyle. The peppermint flavor is bold and more enduring than some natural alternatives, which I appreciate. Although, the inclusion of aspartame might deter some health-conscious consumers. The value is unbeatable, getting 12 packs at a reasonable price.

6. Zellie’s Dental Gum with Xylitol

Zellie’s simplicity and commitment to xylitol without aspartame makes it a standout for me. It meshes well with a variety of dietary needs, including vegan and kosher. The minty taste is pleasantly pure, but, like others, doesn’t hang around as long as I’d like. The price point is a tad high for 100 pieces, but for those prioritizing dietary compliance and natural sweeteners, it may be worth the investment.

7. Xylichew Sugar-free Gum with Xylitol

Appealing to the health-conscious gum chewer, Xylichew bases its formula on xylitol and natural flavor sources. While I respect the brand’s commitment to non-GMO ingredients and dietary inclusivity, the flavor experience starts strong but fades quicker than I’d expected. The texture is agreeable, not too hard nor too soft. A pack of 50 pieces asks for a bit more investment upfront, which might make or break the deal for some.

8. Eclipse Sugar-free Chewing Gum

Eclipse offers a sugar-free experience with a blend of sorbitol and aspartame among its sweeteners. The peppermint flavor strikes a nice balance between intensity and refreshment. Despite its lower rating, the relatively affordable price for eight packs makes it a tempting offer. However, the artificial sweetener mix and the shorter-lived flavor could deter some.

9. Extra Sugar-free Chewing Gum

Extra’s offering is another budget-friendly, sugar-free option where sorbitol and aspartame lead the ingredients list. It’s a classic choice that delivers a satisfactory minty burst, albeit one that doesn’t stick around for the long haul. The pack size and price are perfect for avid gum chewers, though those avoiding artificial sweeteners might pause.

10. Wrigley’s 5 Sugar-free Chewing Gum

With its stylish packaging and a robust minty flavor, 5 Gum from Wrigley’s tries hard to stand out. The sugar-free blend includes a mix of artificial sweeteners, which provides a lasting freshness that’s hard to beat at this price. The flavor longevity and texture are notable, though the artificial sweetener blend may not appeal to everyone.

11. Dentyne Ice Sugar-free Chewing Gum

Dentyne Ice wraps a chilling peppermint flavor in a sugar-free package, promising long-lasting freshness. The quick burst of coolness is invigorating, but I find the flavor starts to wane sooner than I’d like. Priced reasonably for nine packs, it’s a decent option for those seeking a sharp mint experience, though it doesn’t quite reach the prolonged enjoyment I’m after.

12. Wrigley’s Doublemint Chewing Gum

Wrigley’s Doublemint takes a more traditional path with its sugar-laden recipe. The classic mint flavor brings a sense of nostalgia, but the sugar and artificial sweeteners mix is a downside for me, given my preference for natural and health-centric options. The abundance of packs per purchase offers value, but the dietary downsides and fleeting flavor make it less appealing to me personally.

Each of these gums brings its unique twist to the peppermint chewing gum market, with varying degrees of success in flavor, healthiness, and value. Depending on your priorities—be it natural ingredients, dietary compliance, or simply the longest-lasting flavor—there’s likely a gum here that matches what you’re looking for.