All the Aspartame-Free Chewing Gums I’ve Tried, Ranked and Reviewed (2024)

In a market flooded with a variety of chewing gums, it’s challenging to find options that are not only tasty but also health-conscious, especially for those of us wanting to avoid aspartame. I took a closer look at some of the best aspartame-free chewing gums available, focusing on their taste, ingredients, health benefits, and any downsides they might have. Here’s what I found:

1. PUR Aspartame-free Chewing Gum

The PUR Company offers a sugar-free, aspartame-free gum sweetened with 100% xylitol, making it a fantastic choice for vegans and those on a keto or diabetic-friendly diet. With flavors like Peppermint and Chocolate Mint, there’s a good variety. Priced at about $5 for a pack of 55 pieces, it’s reasonably affordable.

My take: I love the variety and the clean feel of these gums, though I did find some flavors to be a bit less intense than I hoped, especially after extended chewing.

2. Simply Gum Classic Natural Chewing Gum

Simply Gum stands out for being aspartame-free and using natural cane sugar as its sweetener. With a broad flavor spectrum including Coffee and Fennel, it caters to unique palates and is compliant with a range of dietary needs. The price tag is a bit steep at approximately $15 for six packs of 15 pieces each.

My perspective: The natural texture and flavors are a big win for me, though the sugar content might not suit everyone, and the gum loses its flavor a bit quickly.

3. Spry Sugar-free Chewing Gum with Xylitol

Spry’s sugar-free, aspartame-free gum is another option sweetened with xylitol and stevia, offering flavors like Licorice and Green Tea. It’s priced at around $9 for a pack of 100 pieces, making it an economical choice.

From my experience: I appreciate the dental health benefits of xylitol, and the variety of flavors is impressive. However, some flavors can feel a bit artificial after a while.

4. Epic Sugar-free Chewing Gum with Xylitol

Another 100% xylitol-sweetened option, Epic Dental’s gum is vegan and keto-friendly, available in interesting flavors like Orange-Mango. A bottle of 50 pieces costs about $6.

Personally speaking: The flavors are bold at first chew, and the oral health benefits are noticeable. My only gripe is that the flavor longevity could be better.

5. Zellie’s Dental Gum with Xylitol

Zellie’s is praised for its dietary compliances and uses xylitol as its sole sweetener. It offers basic flavors like Peppermint and Cinnamon for around $14 per 100 pieces.

My thoughts: The flavor purity is fantastic and it feels refreshing. However, the price point is slightly higher compared to others, which might be a consideration for some.

6. Xylichew Sugar-free Gum with Xylitol

Lastly, Xylichew also opts for a 100% xylitol-based sweetener in its formula, offering both common and unique flavors such as Black Licorice. It’s priced at $10 for a pack of 50 pieces.

In my opinion: The natural feel and taste are great, and it’s comforting to know it’s non-GMO and suitable for a range of diets. The texture can be a bit tough at the beginning, though.

While each of these aspartame-free chewing gums has its merits, the choice ultimately depends on personal preference regarding taste, texture, and dietary needs. It’s refreshing to see the commitment to natural, health-conscious ingredients across the board, making any of these a decent pick for those looking to chew gum without the worry of aspartame.